Debt Consolidation and Debt Settlement: Know the Difference

by Joe Plemon on July 4, 2011

There is no "quick fix" for your debt problems

Whereas debt consolidation companies and debt settlement companies have some similarities (with both, you send one monthly payment in lieu of several), they are, in reality, quite different. Allow me to explain.

Debt Consolidation Companies

Debt consolidation companies are lenders who will consolidate your various debts into one loan, often at a lower payment than the total of your current payments. Sounds good, right? But beware: lower payments often mean you are stretching your debt over a longer period of time. Beware also of a false feeling of accomplishment; some borrowers, because they no longer receive those credit card statements, convince themselves that they have taken care of their debt. Wrong! It has simply been moved. In fact, according to the Dave Ramsey web site, 78% of those who take out debt consolidation loans allow the original debt to grow back. Can a debt consolidation loan help? Yes…if you trade several high interest loans for a single lower interest loan AND change the habits which created the debt in the first place.

Debt Settlement Companies

Debt settlement, on the other hand, is a strategy to withhold payment from your creditors, hoping they will be become so concerned that they will eventually accept less total payment (called a settlement) to erase the debt. It works like this: the consumer sends monthly payments to the debt settlement company, who places them into an escrow account while waiting until the creditors are worried enough to agree to a settlement. The money in the escrow is then used to make this settlement.

This practice, besides being devious, is fraught with other problems. You will trash your credit score and could pay unreasonable fees to the settlement company. I recently met with a man who was sending $490 a month to a debt settlement company, who skimmed $420 for their fees and administration. Run, don’t walk, from debt settlement companies.

The best debt strategy is to develop a budget, tighten your lifestyle, get an extra job (or two) and attack the debt with ferocity.

Readers: have you used either a debt consolidation or debt settlement company?  How did it go?


{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

ella July 6, 2011 at 4:45 pm

Never had to thank G-d but your quote is dead on, a budget is the number one debt killer. now if it was only as easy to create as to say it:/


joeplemon July 7, 2011 at 2:09 pm

Yep. It is easier said than done, but hitting that debt head on sure beats trying to out maneuver it. An old saying is, “You can’t borrow your way out of debt.” So, so true.


Leave a Comment

{ 3 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: